Christian Home Educators Association-Against Initiative

CHEA does not support the Educational Savings Account Initiative as put forth by California School Choice due to the threat it poses to private homeschooling freedoms.

CHEA is aware of the Educational Savings Account Ballot Initiative currently circulating petitions. In keeping with our mission to promote private Christian home education and to protect parents’ rights to direct their children’s education and upbringing, we do not support the initiative due to the threat it poses to private homeschooling freedoms.

Government Money, Government Strings

Seldom does government funding not include government regulation. In keeping with the history of public funding of private educational institutions, these may come in the form of government-directed teacher qualifications, curriculum content, and testing regardless of the protections for private schools the framers have included. The protections built into the current initiative are too vague to adequately address the very real concerns that come with funding, both directly and indirectly, homeschooling specifically and private schools as a whole.

Looking at the history of charter school law, the original intent was to put control and decision making back into the hands of parents and educators. Regulations were introduced incrementally over the years. Thirty years later, it is now highly regulated under state control, not in the hands of parents or the local educators. Like charter school law, with the passage of an ESA initiative, we can expect that more regulations will come; incrementally and regardless of the framers’ original intent.

A Cautionary Tale

Another phenomenon that took place with the passage of charter school law was the emergence of an industry of high priced educational service providers built around the proliferation of educational funding. Time honored extracurricular providers such as dance studios and music studios also began accepting state funds. What followed next? With the proliferation of funds, all families, regardless of whether their children were enrolled in charter schools, faced paying higher prices for their children’s extracurricular activities. Eventually, dual price structures started to emerge. Those families who paid with educational funds were charged higher fees than those who paid “out of pocket.”

Why should we not expect the cost of private education to increase with the proliferation of public funds? Private school tuition that was once $10,000 per year could become $20,000, and so on, regardless of whether a family chooses to take government funding or not.

A Very Real Concern

California is one of 13 states where private home educators operate according to laws governing private schools. We have been doing so successfully for many years. In 2008, California’s Fourth District Court of Appeals definitively declared that parents may legally educate their children under the private school statutes.

Still, the term “homeschooling” is not a legally recognized term and is not used in the California Education Code. We are concerned that use in this initiative will invite scrutiny and definition by our liberal and progressive legislators. Doing so will likely remove us from the protection of the private school statutes and result in additional regulation. This would effectively change California from one of the best states for homeschooling to one of the most restrictive.

In Conclusion

We are aware of parents’ disillusionment with California’s public education system. And we are sympathetic to parents who are seeking financial relief from the costs of education outside of that system. Regardless, the ESA initiative poses a very real threat to private homeschooling freedom, and risks negative impact on all private schools with or without a campus.

We maintain that homeschooling under the private school affidavit option provides parents with the most liberty to direct the education and upbringing of their children to the glory of God. We have consulted with Family Protection Ministries and Home School Legal Defense Association and appreciate their assistance analyzing this initiative.

For more information on government funding of private education, see the article by Nathan Pierce of Family Protection Ministries, Should We Take Government Money for Private Education?

More events

5 Characteristics of Biblical Discipline

5 Characteristics of Biblical Discipline

Five Characteristics of Biblical Discipline The Necessity of Discipline To deter destruction (Heb. 12:4) – Discipline is discipleship! The Means...

Don’t Let Fear Keep You

Don’t Let Fear Keep You

I remember looking back almost four years ago when I decided to homeschool my children. I had experienced a compelling...

Belonging to Community

Belonging to Community

Each day, I am overjoyed to homeschool my children, and my life has become richly blessed by educating my children...

Motivating Chore Charts

Motivating Chore Charts

Our kids (ages 6 & 4) enjoy helping around the house, and each has their own chores. Some days the...

A Father’s Role

A Father’s Role

Father’s Equipping Children As a home school father, I have the essential job of being the school’s principal, as my...

Juggling Kids

Juggling Kids

Tips for Less Stress and More Fun While Homeschooling Little Ones 1. Pray without ceasing!: Seriously though, before homeschooling, this...

Top Ten Reasons To Homeschool

Top Ten Reasons To Homeschool

Last year I was at a leadership conference of Christian homeschool support group leaders, and we participated in a town...

Ways To Discipline Your Kids

Ways To Discipline Your Kids

Our families were asked in an open forum town hall meeting how they discipline their kids, and here are their...

Why I Chose A PSP Over Charter School

Why I Chose A PSP Over Charter School

I often get asked why I chose a PSP over a Charter, and every time, my heart speeds up just...

The Token System

The Token System

When I first started homeschooling last year, it became clear that I was going to have to be very creative...

The Beauty Of The Homeschooling Journey And Avoiding The Comparison Trap

The Beauty Of The Homeschooling Journey And Avoiding The Comparison Trap

I have spent a lot of time over the past year thinking about the “comparison trap” and how easy it...

Sweet Memories

Sweet Memories

Since my son, George, graduated high school last year, I could finally clear out all the homeschool papers, books, and...

Read Aloud Mini Unit Study

Read Aloud Mini Unit Study

This month let’s visit a mom and her young children getting ready to read aloud from The Trumpet of the...

Coaching Your Child—Good Habits!

Coaching Your Child—Good Habits!

Happy Fall! We’re still early in a new school year. Let’s chat about coaching your children to build healthy life...

Christian Home Educators Association-Against Initiative

Christian Home Educators Association-Against Initiative

CHEA does not support the Educational Savings Account Initiative as put forth by California School Choice due to the threat...

Enhancing Creativity & Relationships in the Seasons of Homeschooling

Enhancing Creativity & Relationships in the Seasons of Homeschooling

There are three seasons of homeschooling for each child. The earliest season is when your child begins kindergarten and ends...

Perspective is Everything

Perspective is Everything

When my son Jack was seventeen, he found himself in a job he loved. But although he was doing something...

Reading Tips

Reading Tips

There is also an AMAZING podcast called “read aloud revival” by Sarah McKenzie. She is a Christian homeschool mama and...

Education With the End in Mind

Education With the End in Mind

If parents want to provide the best form of education to their children, they must research the educational findings toward...

Qualities Needed In Trials

Qualities Needed In Trials

I am marinating in the Book of James. WOW it’s a book of deep challenges and pure Ethics of Christianity. ...

Filling Your Cup

Filling Your Cup

From birth to approximately 6th grade, my goal was to advertise the joy of wonderful books by reading aloud each...

Welcome To Your New Family!

Welcome To Your New Family!

Dear Parents, When I decided to start homeschooling our son Jack in 2001, there was little to no support for...

Summer Reading Goals

Summer Reading Goals

Hi Friends, Let me first introduce myself! My name is Loretta Lambert, and I homeschooled my four children for twenty-three...

October Parent Meeting

October Parent Meeting

Oct 3, 2023

Join us for our monthly parent meeting and come together with fellow homeschool parents to discuss strategies, get advice, and...

Book Fair

Book Fair

Oct 10, 2023

Come one, come all to the Book Fair, where you’ll find a fantastic selection of books! The fair will feature...

Bates Nut Farm

Bates Nut Farm

Oct 20, 2023

Join us on Friday, October 20 for an unforgettable autumn experience at Bates Nut Farm, including a fun-filled pumpkin presentation,...

Mission San Luis Rey

Mission San Luis Rey

Nov 9, 2023

Explore the historic Mission structures and extensive grounds that tell the story of our nation’s frontier past and California’s proud...

Mission San Juan Capistrano

Mission San Juan Capistrano

Nov 30, 2023

Mission San Juan Capistrano, a historic landmark and museum, is the Birthplace of Orange County. Founded more than two hundred...

California Field Trip-World Strides

California Field Trip-World Strides

Mar 14, 2024

World Strides registration Letter Trip ID: 211491